Not that I would ever want to leave you with a less than favourable impression of any particular Haley Film that may or may not have been favourably received... because in the end, it still is a Haley Film... and that means a great many positives are always worth noting. How about that, this sampling from the critics seemed to agree...

Osment, once again proving himself the equal of adult actors in the complexity and depth of his performance.

Roger Ebert
Chicago Sun-Times

 

Surpassing even these Oscar winners, though, is Osment, the young Sixth Sense star who displays even more emotional range. I usually suspect that great youth performances are the result of careful casting and manipulative direction. Haley, though, is already a superb actor. We're carried through "Pay It Forward" by the boy's emotional development, his concern for people and his innate goodness and growing courage. We believe his every gesture, statement, action and reaction.

Jack Garner
Rochester Democrat and Chronicle

 

Osment, conveying sad wisdom beyond his years, proves that last year's turn in "The Sixth Sense" was no fluke.

David Germain
Associated Press

 

You witness the first, testing, tension-packed conversation between Spacey and Osment, as pregnant in its silences as in its words, and you are ready to go wherever this movie leads you. Nonetheless, none of that prepares the viewer for the shocking twist near the end of the film that comes out of the blue.

Susan Stark
Detroit News

 

Undeniably one of the best, if not the best, child actors working today, Haley Joel Osment proves here that his performance in "The Sixth Sense" was no fluke. Although his character is occasionally subjected to those same melodramatic moments befalling his costars, Osment sidesteps falling into their trappings. What ultimately saves the film are the performances from its Oscar winning trio of thespians who embody the story's emotionally injured characters.

ScreenIt.com

 

Osment continues the naturalistic simplicity of his Sixth Sense performance. At one point his character runs away to a bus station, to escape his messed-up home life, and is caught there by his mom and the teacher. Osment looks like a gust of wind could knock him over, but at this moment his grown-up sense of despair and disgust are shocking.

Robert Horton
Film.com

 

Worth going to see, mainly for Osment's superb thespian abilities.

Alli Joseph
TNT'S Rough Cut

 

Haley Joel Osment proves that his intuitive Oscar effort in "The Sixth Sense" was no fluke. "Pay It Forward's" cornball concept scores a direct hit to the reflexes. I was glad I grabbed a handful of concession napkins. Judging by the chorus of sniffles, I wasn't alone.

Susan Wloszczyna
USA Today

 

There's something that gets to you about the gravity with which Osment wearily takes his mom's latest bottle of vodka from its latest hiding place and pours it down the sink. No less than the weight of sadness his haunted kid in ''The Sixth Sense'' bore, his face on this occasion speaks of a weight of responsibility he resents bearing when the parent-child roles are reversed in his broken family. "Pay It Forward" is carried to an amazing degree by its performances. It's the kind of film you've got to admire simply for the way it squares its shoulders and plunges into a message of unfashionable idealism.

Jay Carr
Boston Globe

 

Good acting by Osment, Spacey and Hunt combined with the audience's desire to see good done is enough to warrant a recommendation for "Pay It Forward."

Brian McTavish
Kansas City Star

Osment truly is as good as it gets where kid thesps are concerned. Endearing but never cloying as a boy resigned to picking up his passed-out mom's vodka bottles late at night but not to growing up without a father in the house. He brings the requisite brightness, determination, hurt and optimism to a multifaceted role.

Todd McCarthy
Variety, Inc.

 

Spacey, Hunt and Haley "I See Dead People" Osment brought a positive feeling home with strong, credible performances (Was there ever a doubt?). Osment, a charmer of a child, makes the perfect center of the movie. Looking at his face, you can really believe he'd have the confidence and kid power to change the world.

Desson Howe
Washington Post

 

Haley Joel Osment is even more extraordinary here than he was in "The Sixth Sense." He's that rare child star who transcends the curse of being a child star.

Eugene Novikov
Ultimate Movies

 

The performances gradually won me over -- and this is due less to the adult cast than to Osment, who is riveting and completely believable, and definitely proves that "The Sixth Sense" was no fluke. Haley Joel Osment does a very good deed for upbeat "Pay It Forward." He displays an intensity and authority that I can't ever remember seeing in a child actor.

William Arnold
Seattle Post-Intelligencer

 

As the de facto adult in his family, Trevor has a steeliness and a fierce determination that Osment is completely comfortable with. The substance and strength he brings to the part, his ability to match intensity with both Spacey and Hunt, show, in case anyone had any doubts, that Osment's performance in "The Sixth Sense" was hardly a fluke. Young as he is, this is quite an actor. The combination of restrained writing and direction top-of-the-line acting is enough to make even confirmed agnostics want to believe in this unashamed fairy tale

Kenneth Turan
Los Angeles Times

 

Osment excels in another tricky role in the film, managing to be cute without being cutesy. "Pay It Forward" works beautifully as a figment of idealism and goodwill and you'll believe this little pipe dreamer who takes it on himself to be guardian angel to the world.

Joe Baltake
Sacramento Bee

 

Osment easily lives up to the acclaim he garnered for "The Sixth Sense." His work as a messiah of altruism is imbued with layers of subtlety and detail.

Philip Booth
Orlando Weekly

 

The idea is simple, sweet and catchy, like a pop song, and "Pay It Forward" is almost as irresistible as Haley's idea.

Terry Lawson
Detroit Free Press

 

Osment, who doesn't get as teary eyed as the commercial would lead you to think, confirms that his talent is real. "Pat It Forward" is intelligent in script and execution, well performed and very touching.

Chuck Schwartz,
Cranky Critic.com

 

Haley Joel Osment proves that he is not a one shot wonder for his performance in "The Sixth Sense." In his portrayal of the right-minded Trevor the inherent intelligence and dedication of the boy is a significant force in the development of the story and Osment meets the need with a professionalism that belies his years. "Pay It Forward" is an odd mix of good acting talent and an under-achieving script that hampers the overall effort.

Robin Clifford
Reeling Reviews

 

Haley Joel Osment is the best.

Fair
kidactors.com/haley

 

 

This article was researched and written by FAIR and originally posted on Haley Joel Osment's Official Fansite , www.haleyjoelosment.net . We are privileged to be given permission by the author to archive this series of articles in celebration of the FIFTH ANNIVERSARY of PAY IT FORWARD here.
Buy PAY IT FORWARD on DVD, Books and music CDs

Visit our companion websites

This fansite is designed and copyrighted © 2003 by comeawayohumanchild.net and is optimised for the 1024 by 768 pixel screen